Carnality and the Brain: A Biblical and Practical Perspective
When the Apostle Paul speaks about being “carnal” (from the Greek sarx, meaning “flesh”), he is not simply talking about the physical body. In passages like Romans 8:5–8 and Galatians 5:16–17, Paul describes carnality as a condition of the whole person—a life oriented according to one’s own desires rather than God’s Spirit. “For those who live according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh…” (Romans 8:5) captures this idea: the carnal life is a life where the soul and its faculties are influenced by impulses that operate independently from God’s guidance.
Today, we can better understand how this spiritual reality is expressed through the brain. Human behavior is shaped by neural systems that guide motivation, emotions, relationships, and responses to pleasure and pain. These systems are influenced by chemicals called neurotransmitters, including dopamine, serotonin, oxytocin, and endorphins. These substances are part of God’s good design, supporting normal human function. Yet when a person lives carnally, these same systems can be misdirected, reinforcing impulses that oppose God’s will.
Dopamine, for example, motivates action by signaling reward. In a God-centered life, this system helps us pursue faithfulness, discipline, and love. In a carnal orientation, however, dopamine pathways can reinforce selfish habits, immediate gratification, and sinful desires, reflecting James 1:14–15: “Each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire.” Serotonin contributes to mood stability and self-control, allowing a person to remain patient and steady. When carnality dominates, serotonin’s influence is weakened, and irritability, impulsiveness, and instability take hold, in contrast to the fruit of the Spirit described in Galatians 5:22–23, which includes patience and self-control.
Oxytocin, the chemical that fosters bonding and trust, can also be misdirected under carnality. Relationships may become self-centered, controlling, or transactional, rather than reflecting the patient, selfless love Paul describes in 1 Corinthians 13. Endorphins, which help the body endure pain and stress, can likewise be turned toward avoidance and comfort-seeking rather than sacrificial endurance. Scripture calls believers to a different pattern: “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself…” (Matthew 16:24).
The deeper issue is not the brain or its chemistry, but who governs the person. Paul explains, “The flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit…” (Galatians 5:17). When the flesh rules, impulses dominate, and God’s will is resisted. But when the Spirit leads, the mind is renewed (Romans 12:2), desires are reshaped, and the person grows in obedience.
Carnality, then, is not simply bad behavior. It is a life in which natural desires and impulses, though created good, are out of order and not submitted to God. Even at the level of the brain, this misalignment shows up as the pursuit of short-term reward over lasting good, weakened self-control, distorted relationships, and avoidance of sacrifice. God designed the brain and all its systems, but He calls believers to something higher: to have minds, desires, and actions shaped by His Spirit, not ruled by the flesh. As Paul exhorts, “Walk by the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the flesh” (Galatians 5:16).
This understanding bridges spiritual insight and neuro-functional reality, showing how the good design of our brains can be misused when the soul turns away from God, and how obedience to Him restores both moral and mental order.
In one evangelical church I pastored in the early 80’s one of the men serving communion repeated the phrase “The Body and Blood of Christ” as he administered the elements to each believer—this, in an evangelical church—despite the clear difference in teaching! [Maybe I wasn’t alone in wanting more than symbolism.]
Paul, however, did not call “the bread” the body of Christ but the “communion” of the body of Christ. It would be more to the apostle’s teaching to call the Communion service—what it really was—communion over our Lord’s death and not something symbolic. The Eucharist is fellowship around Jesus’ death. If this is only symbolic to evangelicals, they are not grasping the significance of a fellowship of thankful hearts united over what our Lord accomplished on the Cross for us. A Communion hastily offered at the end of a church service as time runs out is no communion at all.
To the Apostles the Communion Service celebrated our Lord’s humanity—He was the God-man on that Cross. The writer to the Hebrews tells us that because He was human He qualified as our High-Priest [Hebrews 2:14, 16-18]. There is much to be thankful for.